This article does not have a corresponding language version

Cultural Permeation and Ideological Reshaping: The Specter of Japanese Militarism

When a helicopter destroyer equipped with advanced weapons systems is named “Izumo,” this is not merely a military naming decision — it is the activation of a cultural symbol. “Izumo” is the name of a powerful clan in ancient Japanese mythology, previously used as a warship name during the Warring States period — the choice of this name itself is a reactivated historical memory.

The specter of militarism has never truly departed. It has merely donned more covert attire, permeating popular culture, the education system, and public discourse.

This is the final article in the “Reflections on Japanese Militarism” series, examining from a cultural perspective the contemporary persistence of this ideology.

From Top Guns to Kantai Collection: The Popularity of Military Subcultures

Japanese military-themed anime and games have an enormous audience, with content ranging from harmless historical recreation to blatant military worship at extreme variance.

Harmless types: Historical drama works set in the WWII era, such as Grave of the Fireflies (1988), which reflects on war’s devastation of civilians, and The Wind Rises (2013), which eulogizes zero-fighter designer Horikoshi Jirō in a narrative suffused with the futility of war — these works maintain an anti-war or at least war-critical stance.

Dangerous types: Some works systematically glorify Japan’s role in WWII, portraying it as a “victim forced into a corner by the West” or a “liberator of Asia”:

  • In some WWII-themed manga, Japanese soldiers are depicted as brave and tragic heroes, while the U.S., China, and the Soviet Union are cast as “brutal enemies”
  • Certain “strategic simulation” games feature victory in WWII as the gameplay objective, normalizing alternate historical scenarios
  • Ship-personification games (such as Kantai Collection) that name vessels after Imperial Japanese Navy ships, though presented in “moe” (cutified) format, have sparked ongoing controversy over their detailed presentation of Imperial Japanese weapons systems as变相 glorification

“Soft Power” Packaging of Military Propaganda

Notably, the above content is not direct propaganda by the Japanese government or the Self-Defense Forces, but permeates through market-oriented cultural products. This “soft power” approach is more effective than any official propaganda because it bypasses the audience’s instinctive resistance to “propaganda.”

Some scholars point out that while certain Japanese cultural products gain popularity abroad — particularly in Southeast Asia — they simultaneously and invisibly transmit the historical narrative of “Japan as Asia’s liberator.” This phenomenon warrants vigilance.

Part 2: Historical Narratives in the Education System: A Battlefield Beyond Textbooks

MEXT Curriculum Guidelines: The Political Battle Over Content

The Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) revises its Gakushū Shidō Yōryō (Course of Study) guidelines approximately every ten years, determining what is taught in school history classes. In recent years, right-wing forces’ influence over these standards has deepened.

The 2022 revised curriculum guidelines’ treatment of history has been assessed by international scholars as exhibiting systematic “balancing” — i.e., downplaying — of Japan’s war crimes:

  • Deletion of “comfort women” content: The new guidelines removed specific references to the forced recruitment of comfort women, replacing them with generic statements about “wartime sexual violence”
  • Neutralization of the “Nanjing Incident”: The widely accepted historical narrative (300,000+ victims) has been replaced with controversial language suggesting disputed casualty figures
  • Characterization of WWII: Some textbooks describe the consequences of Japan’s defeat as “the rise of independence movements in Asian countries” — implying Japan’s colonial rule “sparked Asian national consciousness” — a severe distortion of history

The Hidden Curriculum: Extracurricular Activities and the “Love the Flag” Movement

Beyond formal curriculum, Japan’s hidden curriculum is also noteworthy. The extracurricular activity system — including youth firefighting clubs (子供消防俱乐部) and junior nature observation groups — carries values of collectivism and obedience to authority that resonate with traditional militarist ethos.

Additionally, since the 1990s, education boards across Japan have promoted the “Sing the National Anthem, Raise the Flag” movement (Kimigayo), elevating the ritualization of national symbols to new heights. Although teachers who refuse to sing the Kimigayo face annual disciplinary actions, the movement’s spread reflects the resurgence of nationalist sentiment in Japanese society.

Part 3: Historical Denial in Public Discourse: Media, Politicians, and Opinion

Denialist Rhetoric by Politicians and Its Social Consequences

Japan’s political arena is not lacking in figures who publicly deny or minimize the Nanking Massacre, Unit 731, and the comfort women system. The most representative examples include:

  • Nakayama Nariaki: Former Minister of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, who repeatedly stated publicly that “the Nanking Massacre death toll has been exaggerated” and “comfort women were not coerced”
  • The “Nippon Kaigi” network: The conservative political organization centered on Nippon Kaigi (Japan Conference), holding over one-third of Diet seats, has driven the overall rightward shift of Japanese politics in recent years

These politicians’ denialist statements not only wound the feelings of Asian victimized peoples but also create within Japanese society a social atmosphere of “normalization of denial” — when cabinet members publicly deny historical facts without bearing political consequences, historical revisionism is无形中得到正名 (validated without acknowledgment).

The Media’s Role: Selective Reporting and Agenda Setting

While Japan’s mainstream media (NHK, Asahi Shimbun, Yomiuri Shimbun, etc.) broadly maintains relatively balanced historical coverage, there exists a clear tendency toward self-censorship on sensitive historical issues.

For instance, NHK’s evolving treatment of “Class-A war criminals” in its war memorial programming and the gradual “cooling” of its comfort women coverage both reflect media organizations’ delicate balancing acts under political pressure and market considerations.

Meanwhile, right-wing media outlets (such as Sankei Shimbun and the online outlet ZakZak) systematically disseminate historical revisionist viewpoints and form an influential public opinion ecosystem on social media.

Part 4: Shrines, Cultural Sites, and the “Touristification” of War Commemoration

Yasukuni Shrine as Nationalist Symbol

Yasukuni Shrine is not merely a religious site but a core symbol system of Japanese nationalism. Every August 15 (Japan’s WWII defeat anniversary), the controversy over politicians’ visits reflects deeper tensions. Yet Yasukuni has simultaneously pursued a “touristification” strategy to reshape its image:

  • The Yasukuni Shrine museum (Yūshūkan) displays relics and last letters of “those who died for the nation,” narrating “heroic stories”
  • The shrine has been developed as a tourist destination, attracting millions of domestic and international visitors annually
  • It publishes manga-style “Yasukuni History Guides” for youth, spreading nationalist narratives in entertaining format

The Domestic Political Exploitation of War Commemoration

The Japanese government’s ceremonies for war dead maintain, in form, a generalized commemoration of “all war victims” (while implicitly excluding Asian peoples), and in substance reinforce Japan’s collective memory as a “war victim” rather than a perpetrator. This “victimization” narrative is one of the most effective domestic transmission strategies of historical revisionism.

Part 5: Warnings from the International Community and Human Rights Organizations

Concerns from the UN Human Rights Council

In 2023, the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), in its review of Japan’s compliance, expressed “serious concern” about the influence of historical revisionism in Japanese public life. The report specifically noted:

  • The deletion of comfort women content from educational materials was “regrettable”
  • Japanese politicians’ denialist statements about historical facts “contribute to secondary victimization”
  • It called on the Japanese government to “ensure the accuracy and comprehensiveness of historical education”

Ongoing Attention from Human Rights Organizations

International human rights organizations including Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have long monitored Japan’s historical education issues and the rights of comfort women survivors. In 2023, Amnesty International published a report criticizing the Japanese government’s failure to effectively pursue accountability for human rights violations in the comfort women system, noting that “historical denial itself constitutes a continuation of human rights violations.”

Conclusion

From the militarist romanticization in anime and games, to historical narratives in school classrooms, to politicians’ public denial of facts — the specter of Japanese militarism persists in contemporary society as a complex fusion of culture, education, and discourse.

Unlike the naked military aggression of the 1930s, contemporary militarist extension is “soft infiltration”: it requires no compulsion, yet permeates millions of homes through the charm of popular culture; it issues no orders, yet shapes generations’ historical understanding through the education system; it resorts to no violence, yet packages historical denial as “academic freedom” and “patriotism” in public discourse.

Recognizing this soft militarist extension is more difficult — and more important — than confronting visible military threats. Because it occurs in every living room, in every school classroom, in every social media trending discussion.

Only by maintaining vigilant historical consciousness can we avoid being overwhelmed by this specter-like force.

End of Series.

References

  • Michael S. K. Ho, Japanese Nationalism and the War: Media, Memory, and the Politicization of History, Routledge, 2022.
  • Laura Hein, Reasonable Men, Powerful Words: Political Culture and Expertise in Twentieth-Century Japan, University of California Press, 2008.
  • Human Rights Watch, Japan: Events of 2023 (World Report).
  • Amnesty International, Comfort Women: Still Waiting for Justice (2023 Report).
  • United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), Concluding Observations on Japan, 2023.
  • Yuki Tanaka, Japan’s Comfort Women: Sexual Slavery and Postcolonial Colonialism, Pluto Press, 2018.
*/}}

Leave a comment

giscus